Pros and Cons of Different Roofing Materials for New York Homes

roofing materials

Get A Free Quote

When it comes to roofing, the choice of material is crucial. Different roofing materials come with their unique set of pros and cons, and the choice can significantly impact the durability, aesthetics, and cost of your roof. New York homes, in particular, need roofing that can withstand a variety of weather conditions, from scorching summers to freezing winters and everything in between. Let’s explore the pros and cons of various roofing materials to assist you in making an informed decision. At Smart Roofers NY, we provide comprehensive roofing services tailored to your specific needs.

asphalt shingles ny roof
Asphalt is a commonplace and popular medium for roofing

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are the number one roofing material used in the US and for a good reason. They offer a blend of affordability, durability, and aesthetic appeal that’s hard to beat.


  • Affordability: Asphalt shingles are among the most affordable roofing materials, making them an excellent choice for homeowners on a budget.
  • Versatility: They come in a variety of styles, shapes, and colors, which allow you to customize the look of your shingles roof to match your home’s aesthetic.
  • Ease of Installation: Asphalt shingles are relatively easy to install and repair, which can lower labor costs.


  • Durability: While asphalt shingles are quite durable, they’re not as long-lasting as some other materials. You may need a roof replacement or repair after about 20 years, depending on the quality of the shingles and the severity of the weather conditions in your area.
metal roofing
Metal roofing can last a lifetime but can resonate noise stronger than other roofs

Metal Roofing

Metal roofing has become popular in the last decade because of its energy efficiency and high durability.


  • Durability: A Metal roof is highly durable and can last up to 70 years with proper maintenance.
  • Weather Resistance: They are particularly resistant to the harsh weather conditions often experienced in New York, making them an excellent choice for long-term resilience.
  • Energy Efficiency: Metal roofs reflect sunlight, reducing the amount of heat absorbed by your house and potentially lowering your cooling costs.


  • Cost: The initial cost of installing a metal roof can be higher than other materials.
  • Noise: During heavy rain or hail in Brooklyn, a metal roof can be noisier than other roofing materials.
slate roofing
Slate roofing adds a touch of elegance to anyone’s roof aesthetic

Slate Roofing

Slate roofs are known for their distinctive, elegant appearance and remarkable longevity.


  • Longevity: Slate is incredibly durable, with a lifespan that can exceed 100 years with proper care.
  • Aesthetics: Slate offers a unique and attractive aesthetic that can increase the curb appeal of your home.
  • Fire Resistance: Slate is highly fire-resistant, offering an additional layer of safety for your home.


  • Weight: Slate is heavier than many other roofing materials, which may require additional structural support.
  • Cost: Slate roofs have a higher initial cost than most other roofing materials.
EPDM Roofing
EPDM Roofing is geared towards flat roofs, of which there is no shortage in Brooklyn!

EPDM Roofing

EPDM roofing is a type of rubber roofing that is particularly well-suited for flat roofs.


  • Durability: EPDM roofs are highly durable and resistant to weather and UV damage.
  • Low Maintenance: They require minimal maintenance and are easy to repair.
  • Cost-Effective: EPDM roofing is more cost-effective than many other roofing options, especially for large flat roofs.


  • Aesthetics: While EPDM roofs are highly functional, some homeowners might not find them as aesthetically pleasing as other roofing options.
  • Installation: The installation process can be more complex and may require a professional with specific experience in installing EPDM roofs.
green roof
Green roofs bring a touch of the wild outdoors to your home!

Green Roofing

Green roofing is a sustainable and eco-friendly roofing option that involves growing vegetation on your rooftop.


  • Environmentally Friendly: Green roofs are proficient in minimizing the impact of stormwater runoff, thereby contributing to water quality preservation. Moreover, they foster an enhanced atmospheric composition by improving air quality. Additionally, they act as a strategic solution to counteract the intensification of the urban heat island phenomenon.
  • Energy Efficiency: They provide excellent insulation, helping to reduce heating and cooling costs.
  • Aesthetics: A green roof can provide a unique and beautiful addition to your home.


  • Maintenance: Green roofs require more maintenance than traditional roofing materials, including regular watering and weeding.
  • Cost: The initial installation cost for a green roof can be higher than traditional roofing options.
roof pavers
Roof pavers are ideal if you plan on using your roof as another floor of your home

Roof Pavers

Roof pavers are a durable and versatile option that can transform your roof into a usable outdoor space.


  • Durability: Roof pavers are incredibly durable and resistant to harsh weather conditions.
  • Versatility: They allow for the creation of rooftop patios, gardens, and more, providing additional living space.
  • Aesthetics: Roof pavers come in various styles and colors, allowing for customization to match your home’s design.


  • Weight: Like slate, roof pavers are heavy and may require additional structural support.
  • Cost: The cost of installing roof pavers can be higher than other roofing options due to the complexities of installation and the need for additional support structures.

Frequently Asked Questions

roof shinglesWhat is the best roof for a new home?

The “best” roof for a new home depends on several factors, including your budget, the architectural style of your home, your personal aesthetic preferences, and the local climate. For many homeowners, asphalt shingles are a great choice due to their affordability and versatility. However, if budget allows and if it suits the style of the home, slate or metal roofing can offer superior longevity and durability.

full roofingWhat are the four most popular types of residential roofing?

The four most popular types of residential roofing are asphalt shingles, metal roofing, wood shakes or shingles, and slate roofing. Each of these options has its advantages and disadvantages in terms of durability, cost, aesthetic appeal, and maintenance requirements.

roof ageWhat roof material lasts the longest?

Copper, slate, and tile roofs can last more than 50 years, and in some cases, as long as 100 years. These materials are highly durable and resistant to many forms of damage, including fire and weather-related wear and tear. However, they are more expensive than other options.

hailstonesWhich roofing system will deteriorate the quickest?

Wood shakes or shingles tend to deteriorate the quickest of the common roofing materials, particularly in climates that are prone to high humidity or rainfall. Without proper maintenance, wood roofs can be susceptible to rot, mold, and insect damage.

leaky roofDo metal roofs leak more than shingles?

No, metal roofs do not inherently leak more than shingle roofs. However, the quality of the installation and the maintenance of the roof can significantly impact its likelihood of leaking. Both metal and shingle roofs can provide excellent protection against leaks when installed and maintained properly.

roof repair emergencyWhat is the number one cause of roof failure?

The number one cause of roof failure is poor installation followed by a lack of regular maintenance. Other common causes include severe weather damage and the use of low-quality or inappropriate roofing materials for a particular climate or building type. Regular annual inspections and timely repairs are key to preventing roof failure.

free estimate
Getting a free binding estimate before any work begins is crucial

Can I get a firm estimate for a new roof in Brooklyn?

Absolutely, getting an estimate for installing a new roof in Brooklyn is as simple as reaching out to us at Smart Roofers NY!

We understand that replacing the roof is a significant investment, and you want to ensure you get the best value. That’s why our team in Brooklyn is committed to providing you with a comprehensive and transparent quote that takes into account your home’s specific needs and budget.

We’ll assess the size and structure of your roof, discuss the best materials for your home, and factor in any specific challenges or requirements your project might have. We believe in providing our customers with all the information required to make the best decision, so our estimates are always detailed and straightforward, with no hidden costs.

To get your estimate, all you need to do is contact us at (929) 491-3661. You can also fill out our “Get A Free Quote” online form with some details about your project, and one of our professional team members will get back to you on the same day.

Remember, at Smart Roofers NY, your satisfaction is our top priority. So, don’t hesitate, reach out to us today and let’s start planning your new roof together!

call smart roofers ny
Contact Smart Roofers NY today and let’s begin transforming your roof into something you can be proud of!


Choosing the correct roofing material for your New York home depends on various factors, including your budget, aesthetic preferences, and the specific needs of your home. Each roofing material has its pros and cons, and understanding these can help you make an informed decision.

Remember, no matter what material you choose, regular maintenance is vital to prolonging the lifespan of your roof. Keep an eye out for signs of damage, especially after severe weather events. Check out our guide on how to spot roof damage after a New York storm for more tips.

If you have a question or need professional advice about choosing the right roofing material for your home, don’t hesitate to contact us at (929) 491-3661. Our team at Smart Roofers NY is always ready to provide expert guidance and top-quality roofing services.

Picture of Mike L.
Mike L.

Mike has been working as a roofer since 1995. He dealt with all roof types & condition. Mike will love to share from his experience with you. Call Smart Roofers NY today!

Table of Contents